Comparative Evaluation of the Bond Strength of Universal Adhesives with and Without Selective Enamel Etching

Authors

  • Raham Zaman Associate Professor, Department of Science of Dental Materials, Bacha Khan Dental College, Mardan, Pakistan.
  • Danish Muzaffar Associate Professor, Department of Science of Dental Materials, Faryal Dental College, Sheikhupura, Pakistan.
  • Fiza Zaheer Tunio Dentist, Department of Dental Materials, Fatima Jinnah Dental College, Karachi, Pakistan.
  • Madiha Umar Assistant Professor, Science of Dental Materials, Avicenna Dental College, Lahore, Pakistan.
  • Rao Subhan Mustafa Khan CHPE, MDS (Dental Materials), DDS, DMD, Consultant Dental Surgeon, Aga Khan Hospital and Head of the Department at Garrison Hospital & Diagnostic Center, Karachi, Pakistan.
  • Samia Subhan Khan CHPE, MDS (Dental Materials), BDS, Assistant Professor, Department of Dental Materials, Jinnah Medical and Dental College, Karachi, Pakistan.

Keywords:

Universal adhesives, Selective enamel etching, Shear bond strength, Phosphoric acid, Adhesive dentistry, Dental enamel

Abstract

Background: Universal adhesives have simplified restorative dental procedures by allowing different bonding strategies. However, the influence of selective enamel etching on their bond strength remains an important consideration.

Objective: To compare the shear bond strength of universal adhesives applied with and without selective enamel etching.

Methods: This comparative in vitro experimental study was conducted in the Department of Dental Materials at Bacha Khan College of Dentistry, Mardan, between 1st November 2025 and 30th April 2026. A total of 152 extracted human permanent teeth were tested, 76 in each group. Selective enamel etching was performed prior to the application of the universal adhesive in Group A, and the universal adhesive was applied alone in Group B. A universal testing machine was used to evaluate shear bond strength. An independent-samples t-test was used for data analysis, and a p-value of 0.05 was used as the cut-off value for statistical significance.

Results: The mean shear bond strength was higher in Group A (20.10 ± 4.10 MPa) than in Group B (17.90 ± 4.00 MPa). The mean difference was 2.20 MPa (95% CI: 0.90–3.50); a statistically significant difference between the groups (p = 0.001).

Conclusions: The results indicated that the selective enamel etching process resulted in better shear bond strength. Long-term investigations were needed to verify this observation.

References

Bourgi, R., et al., A literature review of adhesive systems in dentistry: key components and their clinical applications. Applied Sciences, 2024. 14(18): p. 8111.

Cadenaro, M., et al., Progress in dental adhesive materials. Journal of dental research, 2023. 102(3): p. 254-262.

Miyazaki, M., et al., Factors affecting the in vitro performance of dentin-bonding systems. Japanese Dental Science Review, 2012. 48(1): p. 53-60.

Kumar, A., et al., COMPARATIVE MICROLEAKAGE ASSESSMENT OF FIFTH, SEVENTH, AND EIGHTH-GENERATION DENTIN ADHESIVES IN CLASS II COMPOSITE RESTORATIONS: AN IN VITRO STUDY. Genetics and Molecular Research, 2026.

Josic, U., et al., The influence of selective enamel etch and self-etch mode of universal adhesives’ application on clinical behavior of composite restorations placed on non-carious cervical lesions: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Dental Materials, 2022. 38(3): p. 472-488.

Gençer, B.K., et al., Effect of surface conditioning protocols on the repair bond strength of resin composite to CAD/CAM blocks: Bioactive‐glass, silica‐coated alumina, or aluminum oxide? European Journal of Oral Sciences, 2025. 133(4): p. e70016.

Kiaei, S., P. Mirzakoucheki Boroujeni, and M. Kazemian, The Role of Adhesive Monomers (10-MDP, 4-META, HEMA) in Hybrid Layer Formation: Optimizing Chemical Adhesion to Hydroxyapatite and Managing Polymerization Shrinkage Stress. Iranian Journal of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, 2026. 45(9): p. 2253-2271.

Darzé, F., et al., Enamel and dentin etching with glycolic, ferulic, and phosphoric acids: demineralization pattern, surface microhardness, and bond strength stability. Operative Dentistry, 2023. 48(2): p. E35-E47.

Koup, M.A. and M.B. Blatz, The Selective Enamel Etch Technique. Compendium of Continuing Education in Dentistry (15488578), 2024. 45(5): p. 243.

Chen, H., et al., Comparison of bond strength of universal adhesives using different etching modes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Dental materials journal, 2022. 41(1): p. 1-10.

De Angelis, F., et al., Bond Strength Evaluation of Three Commercial Self-Etch Adhesives on Dentine and Etched or Unetched Enamel. Coatings, 2026. 16(10): p. 1166.

Krikheli, N.I., M.N. Bychkova, and E.V. Savrasova, [Comparative evaluation of the shear bond strength of a universal adhesive system in different etching modes and a total etch adhesive system]. Stomatologiia, 2022. 101(3): p. 7-11.

Jäggi, M., et al., Shear bond strength of universal adhesives to human enamel and dentin. J Esthet Restor Dent, 2024. 36(5): p. 804-812.

Amran, T., et al., Impact of phosphoric acid etching duration on the bonding performance of universal adhesives on enamel: a systematic review of laboratory studies. Journal of Esthetic and Restorative Dentistry, 2026. 38(4): p. 780-791.

Krikheli, N.I., M.N. Bychkova, and E.V. Savrasova, [Comparative evaluation of the shear bond strength of a universal adhesive system in different etching modes and a total etch adhesive system]. Stomatologiia (Mosk), 2022. 101(3): p. 7-11.

Suzuki, M., et al., Bond durability of universal adhesives to intact enamel surface in different etching modes. European journal of oral sciences, 2021. 129(2): p. e12768.

Baba, Y., et al., Effects of Different Tooth Conditioners on the Bonding of Universal Self-etching Adhesive to Enamel. J Adhes Dent, 2021. 23(3): p. 233-242.

Krikheli, N., M. Bychkova, and E. Savrasova, Comparative evaluation of the shear bond strength of a universal adhesive system in different etching modes and a total etch adhesive system. Stomatologiia, 2022. 101(3): p. 7-11.

Falcione, D., et al., Influence of application modes on increasing bond strength longevity of self-etching and universal adhesive systems to enamel. Operative Dentistry, 2024. 49(1): p. 52-64.

Hamdy, D., et al., Effect of Application Mode and Aging on Microtensile Bond Strength of Universal Adhesives to Enamel of Primary Teeth. International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry, 2025. 35(4): p. 815-828.

do Nascimento Foly, J.C.S., et al., Bonding performance of universal adhesive systems to enamel–Effects of the acidic composition. Dental Materials, 2025. 41(3): p. 272-282.

Cal, I.K., et al., Effect of different surface treatments on the shear bond strength of one-step and two-step universal adhesives to enamel and dentin. BMC Oral Health, 2026. 26(1): p. 2205.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-20

How to Cite

Zaman, R., Muzaffar, D., Tunio, F. Z., Umar, M., Khan, R. S. M., & Khan, S. S. (2026). Comparative Evaluation of the Bond Strength of Universal Adhesives with and Without Selective Enamel Etching. International Journal of Pharmacy Research & Technology (IJPRT), 16(2), 8698–8705. Retrieved from https://www.ijprt.org/index.php/pub/article/view/3657

Issue

Section

Research Article