Comparative Evaluation of Airway Management Devices in ENT Surgery
Keywords:
Airway Management, ENT Surgery, Laryngeal Mask Airway, Tracheal Intubation, Videolaryngoscopy, Adenotonsillectomy.Abstract
Background: Airway management in ear, nose and throat (ENT) surgery is unusually demanding because the surgeon and the anaesthesiologist share the same anatomical field, and because the airway itself may be the site of disease, instrumentation or bleeding. The choice of airway device therefore influences surgical access, ventilation, airway protection, haemodynamic stability and quality of recovery.
Objective: To compare the principal airway management devices used in ENT surgery, namely cuffed oral and nasal tracheal tubes, supraglottic airway devices (with emphasis on the flexible reinforced laryngeal mask airway), and laryngoscopic and fibreoptic intubation aids, across clinically relevant domains.
Methods: A structured narrative review of randomized trials, systematic reviews, meta-analyses, audits and national guidelines was undertaken, and the findings were organised within a six-domain comparison framework covering airway security, surgical access, physiological response, complications, recovery, and resource and training requirements. No new patient data were collected.
Results and Discussion: In paediatric adenotonsillectomy, which has the strongest evidence base, the flexible reinforced laryngeal mask is an effective alternative to the tracheal tube in experienced hands, with comparable overall adverse events, less blood soiling of the airway and a smoother emergence, but also a longer operative time, a small rate of conversion to intubation, and device-specific problems of kinking and displacement. For predicted difficult airways, videolaryngoscopy improves the glottic view and reduces failed intubation relative to direct laryngoscopy, and awake techniques remain central where airway patency is threatened. Evidence outside tonsillectomy is thinner and more heterogeneous. A device-selection framework linking patient, procedure and team factors is proposed.
Conclusion: No single device is superior across ENT procedures. Device selection should be individualised, guideline-concordant and supported by training, and adequately powered trials in non-tonsillar ENT surgery are needed.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Authors

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.



